The two former Premier League stars reflected their former clubs while discussing the Portuguese star's return to Old Trafford
Jaime Carragher and Peter Schmeichel traded barbs over Manchester United's signing of Cristiano Ronaldo as the former Liverpool defender says he thinks the deal will prove to be a bad one for his former rivals.
Ronaldo moved to Man Utd this summer, returning to the club 12 years after he initially departed for Real Madrid to continue his push towards being regarded as one of the best of all time.
And, with his return, Schmeichel says Manchester United can now reach a new level while Carragher isn't so sure.
"I've never seen so many ex-Manchester United players almost looking love-struck by the sign of Cristiano Ronaldo so it's a huge moment for them," Carragher said on a call promoting CBS' coverage of the Champions League in the U.S.
"He is one of the greatest players of all time, no doubt, but I actually think it may have a negative effect on Manchester United."
In response, Schmeichel fired back at the ex-Liverpool centre-half, saying that he believes that Ronaldo has what it takes to take Man Utd to a new level.
"I don't think you said anything wrong, but there's a word that you said: 'I think it will have'. I think you should say, 'I hope there is a negative effect'. It's a big, big difference. I don't think there is a negative effect in that signing," said the former Red Devils goalkeeper.
"I think it's a marquee signing. It's one of the best signings that the club has made in 10 years, and it's something we as fans, we've been hoping for something of this calibre.
"People say that he's way past the sell-by date, that he wasn't as good as he has been when he was that Juventus but the fact is, in his weak season, which is three years ago at Juventus, he scored 28 goals. Last season he scored 37 goals.
"If you can score half that or add half those goals to a Manchester United season, then it's going to be a fantastic season.
"Also because of who he is, the experience he has at the international level, it gives us a shot of competing at to the very end in the Champions League. PSG this season, it looks on paper, it looks like an unbeatable team but they have got a lot to prove. And so has Liverpool."
Ronaldo could make his long-awaited second debut at Old Trafford as soon as this weekend, with Man Utd set to play host to Newcastle.
After that, Ole Gunnar Solskjaer's side will visit Young Boys on Tuesday for their first Champions League group stage match of the new season.
Ronaldo move 'bad news' for Van de Beek, says agent